Exploitation Spanning Hiring, Training, and Beyond

Exploitation Spanning Hiring, Training, and Beyond

In Germany, foreign trainees are an integral part of the dual vocational training system, a renowned education model that offers a blend of theoretical and practical learning. These trainees, hailing from various countries, are protected by a robust legal framework designed to ensure fair practices and secure contracts.

Protections for Foreign Trainees

The Vocational Training Act (Berufsbildungsgesetz, BBiG) lays the foundation for the dual system, ensuring apprenticeship contracts meet defined standards. Other laws such as the Young Persons (Protection of Employment) Act (Jugendarbeitsschutzgesetz), the Social Code (Sozialgesetzbuch), and the Works Constitution Act (Betriebsverfassungsgesetz) provide additional protections [3].

Apprentices are entitled to a formal training contract and a minimum wage, with collective agreements setting different training allowances [3]. Foreign trainees from outside the EU require a visa for vocational training or a residence permit for the purpose of training, regulated under §16a Residence Act [1].

Recruitment Practices and Challenges

While Germany's recruitment practices are regulated to prevent exploitative fees, some countries lack such regulations, leading to excessive recruitment fees and exploitative practices [4]. In Germany, such fees would conflict with the legal protections offered to apprentices [3][4].

Thuy Tien Vu, a 35-year-old restaurant specialist from Vietnam, is one such trainee who has experienced exploitation in a German hotel. Vu is one of tens of thousands of young people recruited from third countries for dual vocational training in Germany, many of them through private recruitment agencies [2].

Nina Hoferichter, a migration and skilled worker immigration specialist at the Goethe-Institut, advocates for binding standards for recruitment agencies in Germany. She hopes the new government will address this issue [1].

A Growing Concern

A growing market of private recruitment agencies has emerged in Germany, with no certification requirement for these agencies. This has raised concerns among educators like Principal Jürgen Dietrich and teacher Ulrike Holaschke, who have observed organized recruitment of young people, especially from Vietnam, and the exploitation, overtime, fear of employers, and dramatic training conditions they have encountered [2].

Despite these challenges, there are initiatives aimed at improving the situation. The network "Unternehmen integrieren Flüchtlinge" has designed a checklist for "cooperation with placement agencies" that is oriented towards the ILO Convention 181 [3].

In the face of adversity, some trainees, like Omar Brahimi from Morocco, have managed to complete their apprenticeships despite the COVID-19 pandemic and initial rejection from a program [3].

As Germany continues to attract young talent for vocational training from third countries, it is crucial to address these challenges and ensure a fair and safe environment for all trainees.

[1] Goethe-Institut (2025). Migration and Skilled Worker Immigration. Retrieved from https://www.goethe.de/ins/de/prj/mig/sup/sai/sai_13174645.html

[2] Die Zeit (2025). The Exploitation of Foreign Trainees in Germany. Retrieved from https://www.zeit.de/2025/06/exploitation-of-foreign-trainees-in-germany

[3] Bundesministerium für Arbeit und Soziales (2024). Dual Vocational Training for Foreign Trainees. Retrieved from https://www.arbeits-und-sozialministerium.de/352460

[4] European Commission (2024). Recruitment Fees and Exploitation of Third-Country Nationals. Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/what-we-do/policy/strategies-and-plans/strategies-and-actions/integration-and-inclusion/recruitment-fees-and-exploitation-of-third-country-nationals_en

1. Foreign trainees play a significant role in Germany's dual vocational training system, an acclaimed education model that offers a balance of theoretical and practical learning.
2. The Vocational Training Act (Berufsbildungsgesetz, BBiG) guarantees the standards of apprenticeship contracts in Germany.
3. Other laws like the Young Persons (Protection of Employment) Act (Jugendarbeitsschutzgesetz), the Social Code (Sozialgesetzbuch), and the Works Constitution Act (Betriebsverfassungsgesetz) provide extra protections for apprentices.
4. Apprentices in Germany are entitled to a formal training contract and a guaranteed minimum wage.
5. For foreign trainees from outside the EU, specific visas for vocational training or residence permits for training purposes are required, based on §16a Residence Act.
6. Excessive recruitment fees and exploitative practices are concerns in some countries, but Germany's recruitment practices aim to prevent such issues.
7. Despite regulation, foreign trainees in Germany may still face exploitation, as demonstrated by Thuy Tien Vu, a restaurant specialist from Vietnam.
8. Private recruitment agencies in Germany have grown without any certification requirements, raising concerns among educators.
9. The network "Unternehmen integrieren Flüchtlinge" has introduced a checklist for cooperation with placement agencies based on ILO Convention 181.
10. Initiatives like this aim to improve the situation for foreign trainees in Germany.
11. Amidst adversity, some trainees, such as Omar Brahimi from Morocco, have persevered to complete their apprenticeship despite the COVID-19 pandemic and initial rejection.
12. To ensure a fair and secure environment for all trainees, it is essential to address the challenges arising in the dual vocational training system.
13. The Goethe-Institut calls for binding standards for recruitment agencies in Germany to prevent future exploitation of foreign trainees.
14. The European Commission is also working on strategies to address recruitment fees and exploitation of third-country nationals.
15. The entertainment industry, from celebrities and pop culture to sci-fi and fantasy, is an engaging realm influenced by the experiences of foreign trainees in Germany.
16. Social media platforms provide space for conversation about the challenges faced by foreign trainees and celebrate their accomplishments.
17. The developments in the dual vocational training system will impact various sectors, including personal finance, technology, and business, as foreign trainees contribute to the economy.
18. The trends in the fashion-and-beauty, food-and-drink, home-and-garden, and lifestyle industries could be influenced by the cultural exchanges that occur through the dual vocational training system.
19. In the realm of sports, from football and baseball to golf and tennis, the performance of foreign trainees adds excitement and competitiveness; meanwhile, sports betting revolves around these events on casino-and-gambling platforms.

Read also: