Skip to content

Glacier mummy Ötzi fails to dispute human-induced climate change hypothesis

Stone Age temperatures were colder than present-day temperatures, according to a graph. Online inquiries question how Ötzi, a prehistoric man, came to be found beneath a glacier. Fact-checking investigation.

The frozen corpse of Ötzi, the Iceman, does not contradict human-induced climate change.
The frozen corpse of Ötzi, the Iceman, does not contradict human-induced climate change.

Glacier mummy Ötzi fails to dispute human-induced climate change hypothesis

In a striking revelation, scientists have uncovered evidence of unprecedented glacier retreat and rising temperatures, particularly in Europe. These findings are based on various studies, including one by Olaf Eisen from the Alfred Wegener Institute for Polar and Marine Research, and Christoph Mayer, a glaciologist at the Bavarian Academy of Sciences.

According to Eisen, the current rate of glacier retreat is unlike anything seen before in the Earth's history, happening at a speed and scale unparalleled from the past. This rapid melting is a cause for concern, as it suggests a significant shift in our planet's climate.

The graph, presented in a Time article, illustrates global temperatures as anomalies from the pre-industrial era. The data shows that Europe is warming faster than any other continent, with a 2.4-degree increase in temperature compared to the pre-industrial period. This rapid warming trend is especially evident in the Northern Hemisphere, where temperatures were above average during the mid-Holocene, about one to two degrees warmer than the global average today.

This warming trend is not a recent phenomenon. Andrea Fischer, a researcher, found in a 2022 study that the area around Ötzi's body was excellent for glacier existence about 5,300 years ago because the climate was colder then, allowing glaciers to form and persist. However, higher temperatures have caused glaciers in that region to retreat or disappear. Interestingly, glaciers around Ötzi's discovery site began to grow again around 5,900 years ago when the climate became cooler.

However, a contradiction arises from an Instagram post, which questions the accuracy of the graph because Ötzi was discovered under a glacier, yet there is a glacier at the site today despite supposedly warmer temperatures. In response, Christoph Mayer points out that the graph shows reconstructions for the global average temperature, and it does not necessarily follow that the course in the Austrian Alps looks the same.

Despite these findings, some sceptics, such as Economist Stefan Homburg, known for misinformation, have questioned the graph's accuracy. Homburg did not respond to the research findings by the time of publication.

The graph covers the period from 10,000 years before our time to the present, with a focus on Ötzi's lifetime. A study shows that globally, the last decade (2011 to 2019) was 0.3 degrees warmer than the warmest phase during the Holocene Climate Optimum around 6,500 years ago. This suggests that the current warming trend is not only unprecedented but also potentially alarming.

The speed of glacier melting is now happening within a few decades, compared to previous rates of 500 years. This rapid melting is a concern for scientists like Olaf Eisen and Christoph Mayer, who believe that the human influence on the climate is much more intense and faster than any past natural climate fluctuations.

Andrea Fischer's 2022 study also revealed that Ötzi had not died at the discovery site and had been briefly exposed several times over the past thousands of years due to melting processes. This discovery underscores the importance of understanding the impact of climate change on our planet and its inhabitants.

In conclusion, the evidence points towards an unprecedented rate of glacier retreat and rising temperatures, particularly in Europe. These findings highlight the need for urgent action to combat climate change and protect our planet's glaciers and other vulnerable ecosystems.

Read also:

Latest