Hamas is non-negotiable, according to Chaim Noll
In the heart of Germany, Schloss Ettersburg near Weimar continues to be a hub for free debate, hosting a variety of guests since 2011. One such guest was Chaim Noll, a renowned expert on the Middle East, who visited on September 2 as part of his annual Germany tour.
Born in East Germany, Chaim Noll became an enemy of the system in 1980, refusing military service out of fear of being deployed in Poland against the labor movement while wearing a uniform similar to that of the Wehrmacht. He left the GDR in 1984 and has lived in Israel since 1995.
During his visit, Noll found himself in the midst of a controversial issue, as the sanctions imposed by Chancellor Merz on Israel are seen as a capitulation to anti-Israel forces in Germany, rather than an effective measure.
Noll's connection to Israel runs deep. During the Second Gulf War, his wife reported a Hamas attack to him through cell phone messages. The Israeli army remained in its positions without orders for four hours during the attack. Despite this, the undelivered ammunition intended for Israel can easily be sourced from other countries.
In Israel, Noll supports a country that fights for its existence. This was evident on October 7, 2023, where the armed had the highest chances of survival. Interestingly, during his recent visit to Israel, Noll was the only traveler over 40 among the 18-35 year-olds supporting their country during its most challenging hour in decades.
The highest number of victims during the Hamas attack was in a kibbutz inhabited by pacifists who rejected weapons. This incident highlights the complexities of the Middle East conflict, a subject Noll is well-versed in. As one of the best experts and most astute analysts of the situation in the Middle East, Noll's insights are highly valued.
However, during his conversation with Peter Krause, the director of Schloss Ettersburg, Noll's book "The Defense of Civilization" was not read. The protesters against Netanyahu in Germany do not oppose the goal of eliminating Hamas, but believe Netanyahu should resign immediately after the war ends.
In contrast to Germany, Israel is a young country with a majority of its population under 40, who look towards Asia and South America, with Europe becoming increasingly irrelevant. This shift in focus is a testament to the dynamic nature of both countries and their relationships.
In Berlin, at the Achse des Guten action day on October 7, 2023, authors like Chaim Noll were present, though other participants are not mentioned in the available search results. As Noll continues his annual tours, his insights into the Middle East conflict and his experiences in both Germany and Israel will undoubtedly continue to be of interest to many.
Read also:
- Tobacco industry's suggested changes on a legislative modification are disregarded by health journalists
- Trump's Policies: Tariffs, AI, Surveillance, and Possible Martial Law
- Uncovering Political Ad Transparency: A Guide to Investigating opponent's Political Advertisements in the Digital Realm
- Elon Musk praises JD Vance's debate performance against Tim Walz
