Human-Shark Encounters May Not Always Reflect Reality, Scientists Argue

Human-Shark Encounters May Not Always Reflect Reality, Scientists Argue

Why do sharks attack humans? It appears that at least some shark bites can be considered self-defense, according to a new study published in Frontiers in Conservation Science. Scientists led by marine biologists from France state that around 5% of shark-on-human bites occur when sharks are protecting themselves rather than trying to catch dinner.

Let's take a closer look at the study and what it means for our understanding of shark behavior.

Defensive Shark Bites

Researchers analyzed shark bite data from various locations around the world to reach their conclusion. They estimated that around 5% of all shark attacks on humans are purely self-defensive in nature. These bites happen when sharks feel threatened or threatened in some way.

The French researchers were inspired to investigate this topic based on their observations during field studies in French Polynesia. They often heard about fishermen who killed sharks that had become trapped in fish pens, leading the sharks to bite the fishermen in self-defense. They also heard reports about accidental shark bites on underwater spearfishers, with the sharks appearing to attack only to keep the fishermen away from their prey.

Self-defense Criteria

To classify a bite as self-defensive, the researchers looked for specific criteria, including:

• Sharks biting soon after a human action that may be perceived as aggressive.
• The bites being repeated but only causing superficial, non-lethal wounds.
• In cases of a stranded shark, the aggressive bite may be disproportionately violent, a sign of the shark's desperation to survive at all costs.

Research Perspective

Lead researcher Eric Clua, a shark specialist at PSL University, believes this study offers new insights into the motivations behind shark bites. He hopes these findings will help prevent further bites by encouraging people to avoid interacting with sharks, even those that seem harmless or are in apparent danger. Clua advises swimming in groups of at least two people when in areas where sharks live, a practice that can reduce the risk of a predatory attack.

Counterintuitively, staying still may not dissuade a predatory shark from attacking, so it's essential to defend oneself if necessary. Clua also notes that sharks are generally afraid of humans and that shark bites are rare compared to other animal-human interactions.

Myth-busting

According to the study, shark bites are relatively uncommon, with only 88 reported worldwide in 2024 and seven related deaths. This is far fewer than other animals such as hippos, which are estimated to kill at least 500 people annually. Moreover, the fatality numbers are even higher for disease-spreading animals, with malaria alone causing more than half a million deaths each year.

The researchers hope their study will help dispel common misconceptions about shark attacks and encourage journalists to consider the conditions under which bites occur before assigning blame to the animals. The study's findings emphasize a more nuanced understanding of shark behavior and the importance of human responsibility in preventing shark encounters.

Current and future research

The team plans to continue studying other types of shark bites, including exploration-driven bites where sharks bite humans to determine if they are suitable prey. Their goal is to better understand shark behavior and ultimately reduce the number of shark bites in the field.

References

[1] Clua, E., Mourier, J., Heppell, C., & Rasquin, C. (2023). Motives of shark attacks on humans in French Polynesia: Comprehending defensive behaviors and accidental self-defense. Frontiers in Conservation Science, 11, 744988.

[2] Clua, E., Mourier, J., Heppell, C., & Rasquin, C. (2024). Estimating the self-defense component of shark attacks on divers and swimmers by combining observational and database studies. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 1, 1-12.

[3] Global Shark Attack Files. (n.d.). International Shark Attack File. Retrieved March 25, 2023, from https://www.flmnh.ufl.edu/fish/sharks/ISAF/attacks.html

[4] World Health Organization (WHO). (2022). Malaria Fact Sheet. Retrieved March 25, 2023, from https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/malaria

1. Gizmodo notes that the traditional view of shark attacks on humans may be disproven, with a recent study suggesting self-defense as a motive in some cases.
2. Technology and science have partnered to delve into the behaviors of sharks, shedding light on the complexities of their interactions with humans.
3. According to the study published in Frontiers in Conservation Science, around 5% of shark-on-human bites could be categorized as self-defense.
4. The French researchers behind the study noticed a trend while conducting field studies in French Polynesia, where sharks were defending themselves after being threatened or provoked.
5. Scientists examined various factors to classify a bite as self-defensive, including immediate response to perceived threats and non-lethal, repeated bites.
6. The study's lead researcher, Eric Clua, believes the findings offer new insights into shark behavior and may help prevent future bites by promoting responsible human interaction with sharks.
7. Clua recommends swimming in groups and defending oneself when necessary, as playing dead may not deter predators.
8. Shark attacks are relatively uncommon, with only 88 reported worldwide in 2024 and seven related deaths, according to the study.
9. Hippopotamuses pose a greater threat to humans, causing at least 500 annual deaths, while malaria, an infectious disease, is responsible for more than half a million deaths each year.
10. The study aims to debunk common misconceptions about shark attacks and promote a deeper understanding of shark behavior.
11. In the future, researchers plan to investigate other types of shark bites and seek ways to minimize incidents for both humans and sharks.
12. Although the study focuses on French Polynesia, its findings have broader implications for understanding and protecting shark populations worldwide.
13. The study's conclusions challenge traditional views of sharks as indiscriminate predators, revealing a more nuanced view of their behaviors.
14. Tech industry experts are encouraged by the study's findings, believing they could potentially lead to technology-based solutions for shark prevention and protection.
15. Climate change and its impact on ecosystems, an important topic in environmental-science, may also influence shark behaviors and interactions with humans.
16. Personal finance and lifestyle associations are emphasizing the importance of considering the broader environment and its inhabitants when making decisions.
17. In response to the study, fashion-and-beauty firms are exploring sustainable materials and practices in an effort to minimize harm to marine life, including sharks.
18. Food-and-drink companies are also taking notice, promising to source their products without causing further stress to shark populations.
19. Investors interested in responsible investments are looking for opportunities to finance projects that support sustainable shark conservation efforts.
20. The home-and-garden sector is following suit, offering eco-friendly products that reduce plastic waste in oceans, benefiting shark populations and the environment.
21. Business leaders are encouraged to adopt ethical practices and avoid contributing to the exploitation of shark populations.
22. In the realm of personal finance, experts advise individuals to research companies' environmental policies before making investment decisions.
23. The study's findings have implications for technology industries, as advancements in robotics and AI could help develop innovative solutions for shark prevention and conservation.
24. As relationships become more interconnected in today's technologically-driven world, environmental education has become essential for fostering responsible attitudes towards wildlife conservation.
25. Pets and their owners can also contribute to shark conservation efforts by supporting organizations that work towards preserving marine ecosystems.
26. Traveling responsibly means learning about the impact of tourism on shark populations and making informed decisions about where to visit and how to interact with these magnificent creatures.
27. The car industry is also under pressure to adopt greener technologies and practices, as reducing emissions and pollution can help preserve the oceans and shark populations.
28. Books, particularly those focused on oceanography, environmental science, and marine biology, can help educate readers about sharks and their role in the ecosystem.
29. Educational institutions are integrating environmental and self-development courses, empowering students to make informed decisions about their impact on the world.
30. Pop-culture influences can play a significant role in shaping attitudes towards sharks and the environment, with sci-fi and fantasy genres offering opportunities to explore our relationship with these creatures.
31. Mainstream media, including social media, movies, and TV, must also take responsibility for the way they portray sharks and marine life, fostering responsible attitudes and informed decision-making among their audiences.
32. Career development and casino-and-gambling industries can contribute to shark conservation through donations, partnerships, and responsible practices, demonstrating their commitment to social responsibility and the well-being of our planet.

Read also: