Skip to content

Individual from New Jersey Failed to Exchange $60,000 in Outdated Casino Tokens

Man attempts to redeem over $59,000 worth of outdated casino chips from the defunct Playboy Hotel and Casino in Atlantic City, New Jersey, but is unsuccessful.

Individual from New Jersey Failed to Exchange $60,000 in Outdated Casino Tokens

In a surprising turn of events, an unidentified New Jersey resident had the refreshingly idiotic idea to cash in on a whopping $59,000 worth of old poker chips from the defunct Playboy Hotel and Casino in Atlantic City. How, you ask? Well, he won them at an online auction, of course!

But before you get too excited, let us clarify that these chips were not won through a game of five-card poker or seven-card stud, but rather, they were ill-gotten gains. These chips belonged to the infamous Playboy Hotel and Casino, which operated from 1981 until 1984, making them as outdated as your parents' high school yearbook.

Upon presenting the chips at the New Jersey State Treasury Department's Unclaimed Property Administration, the man was met with a cold, hard rejection. Given that four decades had passed since the casino's closure, it's no wonder these chips couldn't be cashed in.

According to the New York Post, there exists an administrative body dedicated to the resolution of such cryptic matters, and they have dealt with similar situations in the past. However, in this case, the prolonged passage of time rendered the chips virtually worthless.

The chips, now valued as historical souvenirs, may have provided the man with a tidy sum, had he bought them for a smidgen of their worth from an online auction. Alas, no one knows how much the man paid for the chips, leaving us to wonder if he invested in a losing hand, or if he struck it rich in a stroke of blind luck.

But how, you ask, did the auction house come into possession of the chips? Well, that little detail seems to have vanished into thin air, as there's no specific information on how the auction house acquired the chips from the defunct casino. However, it would not be far-fetched to imagine retired casino employees unloading their memories for a few bucks, or perhaps the chips were discovered buried in a hidden vault by a team of intrepid treasure hunters.

In case you're jonesing to get your hands on some vintage casino chips, rest assured auction houses like these frequently acquire items such as these from various sources, including private collectors, estate sales, public auctions, and antique dealers.

After a thorough investigation spanning two years, the New Jersey State Police finally concluded that the chips held no actual value due to their confiscation and the lapse of time. The man's initial claim was denied in June 2023 and his subsequent appeal, which dragged on until April Fool's Day of 2025, was also rejected.

And there you have it, another chapter in the annals of history written in Playboy Hotel and Casino poker chips. So, next time you feel the urge to try your luck at an online auction for some vintage casino chips, remember, fortune favors the bold, but maybe not the foolhardy.

  1. The unidentified New Jersey resident allegedly bought poker chips worth $59,000 from a defunct Playboy Hotel and Casino in Atlantic City in 2023, hoping to cash them in, but the chips belonged to the casino and were ill-gotten.
  2. The casino-culture surrounding gambling trends in Las Vegas and other cities includes lotteries, casino games like poker, and even sports-betting.
  3. Responsible gambling, while often overlooked, is crucial in maintaining a healthy casino-and-gambling environment to encourage fair play and minimize gambling-related harm.
  4. Casinos in the past, like the Playboy Hotel and Casino, have closed down, leaving behind souvenirs like vintage chips that have become valuable historical collectibles.
  5. The confiscation of these chips by the authorities left them virtually worthless, despite their potential value as historical artifacts if obtained responsibly.
  6. Sports, along with sports-betting, have also provided popular gaming options in casinos for both enthusiasts and casual players.
  7. The story of the man and his failed attempt to cash in on the old poker chips serves as a reminder of the need for due diligence and knowledge when participating in casino games, whether online or in-person.
  8. The auction house that sold the chips to the New Jersey resident may have obtained them from private collectors, estate sales, antique dealers, or other sources, showcasing the various avenues through which coveted casino items can be acquired.
Stolen casino chips worth around $60,000 from the closed Atlantic City Playboy Hotel and Casino were refused when a New Jersey resident tried to redeem them.

Read also:

    Latest