Skip to content

Trump's tariff matter under legal scrutiny: Tariff-related issues in court

Trade policy of U.S. President Donald Trump under legal scrutiny after court loss; however, potential future decisions remain unclear.

Courtroom Showdown: Tariffs' Impact on Trump's Policies Examined
Courtroom Showdown: Tariffs' Impact on Trump's Policies Examined

The ongoing legal battle over President Trump's authority to impose tariffs without consulting Congress has taken a new turn, with the U.S. Supreme Court set to decide whether the president had the power to bypass Congress for these tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act.

In April, President Trump announced high tariffs against a large number of countries, including China, Mexico, and Canada. However, a federal appeals court ruled most of these tariffs illegal, blocking many tariffs imposed in April and earlier. The decision does not take effect until October 14, allowing the U.S. government time to appeal to the Supreme Court.

The lower instance decision referred to an earlier status from April, where the judges denied President Trump the authority to invoke a 1977 law without consulting Congress to justify tariffs. Trump had argued that there was an emergency, which allowed him to invoke the 1977 law without consulting Congress.

The judges emphasized that tariffs are a core competence of the U.S. Congress. They also highlighted that the tariff was the result of lengthy negotiations between the two parties. However, it is unclear how the judges' decision might affect the existing tariff.

Duties on cars, steel, aluminum, pharmaceuticals, and semiconductors were not affected by the previous federal court decision. A tariff rate of 15% has been applied to most products imported from Germany and other EU countries to the U.S. since August 7, following an agreement between Trump's government and the EU. Some tariff rates were reduced, while for some countries they were further increased. In return, U.S. tariffs on car imports from Germany and other countries are to be reduced.

Trump has written on his Truth Social platform that "ALL TARIFFS REMAIN IN EFFECT!", and he is planning to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's conservative majority is being hoped to rule in Trump's favor.

The U.S. court's decision comes amidst Trump's claims of an imbalance in international trade to the detriment of the U.S. and that the country has been treated unfairly. Trump continues to use the alleged emergency as an argument.

On Thursday, the European Commission launched the legislative process to abolish tariffs on U.S. industrial goods and reduce barriers to the import of certain food products. This move is expected to further complicate the already complex trade relations between the U.S. and the EU.

As the Supreme Court prepares to make its decision, the future of these tariffs remains uncertain, with potential implications for international trade and relations.

Read also:

Latest