Unanticipated audio file leak escalates tension: Menendez brothers' parole heard denied following audio leak
In a dramatic turn of events, the parole hearings for the infamous Menendez brothers, Erik and Lyle, took place at the California Department of Corrections Rehabilitation headquarters near Sacramento this week. The hearings, which were typically closed to the public, were thrown into turmoil when a recording of Erik's hearing was inadvertently made public.
ABC7 published the recording, reportedly in response to a public records request. However, the release of the audio caused a stir, with several relatives of the brothers deciding not to testify due to the leak. Parole Commissioner Julie Garland stated that audio of parole hearings could be released under the California Public Records Act, but the organization responsible for the release remains unknown.
The audio recording of Erik's parole hearing was forbidden except by state prison officials. Heidi Rummel, parole attorney for both Erik and Lyle Menendez, asked for a break and at one point asked that the hearing be adjourned due to the audio's release. Rummel had previously objected to media access to the hearing and implied at one point that media access had led to a "leak".
In a statement, Garland clarified that audio from Friday's hearing would not be released publicly until Rummel had the opportunity to object in court or contest its release. The two-member parole board ultimately decided the audio incident would not deter them from making a ruling late Friday evening.
Meanwhile, the parole board denied Erik's petition after an all-day session, meaning he will remain in prison. Lyle's request was also rejected, ensuring he will continue his incarceration. Both brothers will be eligible for parole in three years, but they can petition for an earlier hearing in one year.
Rummel stated that she would be looking to seal the transcript of the hearing under Marsy's Law, a California law designed to protect victims' rights. The decision not to grant parole has been met with controversy, particularly given the recent change in Los Angeles County District Attorney.
New District Attorney Nathan Hochman moved to oppose the petition after he defeated Gascón in the November election. Gascón had previously petitioned a judge to have the Menendez brothers' sentences reduced to 50 years in prison, making them eligible for parole.
As the case continues to unfold, the public awaits further developments and decisions regarding the Menendez brothers' futures.
