Skip to content

Vaccine compensation at risk due to Kennedy's proposals

U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr plans a comprehensive revamp of the federal vaccination injury compensation system.

Vaccine compensation faces imminent jeopardy under Kennedy's proposals
Vaccine compensation faces imminent jeopardy under Kennedy's proposals

Vaccine compensation at risk due to Kennedy's proposals

In the current climate of heightened sensitivity surrounding vaccines in the United States, the appointment of Robert F. Kennedy Jr as the new United States Secretary of Health and Human Services has stirred controversy. One of his first announced intentions is to overhaul the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP).

Established in 1986, the VICP provides a no-fault route for individuals who claim to have suffered injury from routine vaccines. Compensation in the VICP is funded by a small excise tax on vaccines. However, the University of Michigan Institute for Healthcare Policy and Innovation has highlighted that caps on compensation in the VICP have not been adjusted for inflation.

Kennedy has expressed his intention to realign the VICP with its original purpose. He has also floated the possibility of eliminating compensation altogether, though he has not explicitly stated that this is his intention. The future of the VICP stands as a critical test of the Kennedy administration's handling of public health policy and its willingness to balance reform with the need to protect both individuals and the broader population.

Public health specialists argue that targeted reforms, such as modernising compensation limits, increasing resources to reduce delays, and improving transparency, would strengthen the VICP without jeopardizing its core function. On the other hand, Kennedy's reforms could potentially weaken or dismantle the VICP, according to medical and legal experts.

If the VICP were to be dismantled or significantly weakened, claimants could face lengthy, expensive litigation in civil courts. This could potentially re-expose manufacturers to costly litigation, repeating the crises of the past. Experts warn that reducing or eliminating compensation in the VICP would harm injured individuals and destabilize vaccine supply.

Alarm has been raised by public health experts, legal scholars, and patient advocates over the prospect of dismantling or curtailing the VICP. They argue that such a move could erode public confidence, discourage vaccine uptake, and threaten herd immunity. KFF Health News notes that backlogs in the VICP have left families waiting years for resolution.

As the review process unfolds, Kennedy's department is now formally reviewing the structure of the VICP in collaboration with the Department of Justice. However, no timetable has been set for legislative proposals. Kennedy has criticized the VICP as "corrupt and inefficient" and has pledged to "fix" it. But, as of now, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has not publicly presented specific reform proposals for the VICP in the USA.

The debate over the VICP underscores the complexities and sensitivities surrounding vaccines and public health policy in the United States. As the review process continues, it remains to be seen how Kennedy's proposed overhaul will shape the future of the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program.

Read also:

Latest