Skip to content

"What Entity Foots the Bill for Excessive Climate Events?"

Differing strategies are employed by California, Florida, and Texas in financing recovery initiatives following fires, floods, and other natural catastrophes, with climate change pushing them to their limits.

Who is Responsible for Financing Severe Weather Events?
Who is Responsible for Financing Severe Weather Events?

"What Entity Foots the Bill for Excessive Climate Events?"

In the face of escalating climate change and increasingly frequent extreme weather events, three major US states - California, Texas, and Florida - are grappling with the financial and societal impacts in distinct ways.

California: Wealthier Citizens Bear the Burden

California, known for its pristine beaches and picturesque landscapes, is facing the challenge of modernizing its power grid. Wealthier citizens are being asked to shoulder this burden, with proposals such as burying power lines to reduce wildfire risks. However, the state's largest homeowner insurance company, State Farm, has stopped selling new coverage to homeowners statewide. In the wake of this, the FAIR Plan, a state-run insurance program, steps in to provide basic but expensive coverage to homeowners who can't get private insurance.

California's financial losses from wildfires are substantial. In 2018 alone, wildfire damages totaled an astounding $102 billion. Moreover, air pollution from these wildfires has made New York City's air quality the worst in the world, adding another layer of concern to the state's environmental woes.

Texas: Blackouts and Subsidies

Texas, the Lone Star State, experienced a massive blackout in February 2021. Millions were left without power for days, and hundreds of people died. The biggest threat to Texas' electricity grid during this blackout was the freezing of natural gas pipelines. To address this issue, Texas is subsidizing the construction of new natural gas power plants and paying for them by adding charges to all residents' power bills and drawing funds from the regressive state budget.

However, Texas is also taking steps to support renewable energy. Lobby organizations representing rural renewable energy interests and utilities are actively trying to convince local governments to ease the process of connecting rural renewable energy projects to the power grid.

Florida: Fighting the Tide

Florida, known for its sunny beaches and vibrant nightlife, is battling rising sea levels and frequent flooding. The state is spending millions to shore up low-lying coastal areas and to salvage the Florida Keys. Despite these efforts, residential properties prone to flooding are overvalued by at least $121 billion.

Moreover, homeowners' insurance premiums have risen significantly in flood-prone areas like Florida and Texas. In a concerning development, Farmers' Insurance has stopped writing new property insurance policies in Florida due to high catastrophe costs and rising prices on factors such as lumber and labor.

Florida is also fighting federal efforts to make publicly subsidized insurance reflect the cost of living in a floodplain in a world with rising water levels. The state is one of ten states suing President Joe Biden's administration over the plan to raise rates for the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP).

A Global Effort: The Green Transition

Amidst these local struggles, a global financing pact is being discussed to accelerate the green transition and help developing economies. The aim is to provide the financial resources needed to combat climate change and build resilient infrastructure.

On June 22, Carnegie California is hosting an event about the state's role as a global policy leader in addressing climate change. The event will undoubtedly shed light on the challenges faced by California, Texas, and Florida and discuss potential solutions for a sustainable future.

As the residents of these states grapple with the realities of a climate-changed future, it's clear that the limits of insurance are being tested, particularly in California, where private insurers are no longer willing to bear the risk of future destruction. The development of insurance for physical assets, a foundational development of modern capitalism, is being pushed to its limits as we navigate the uncharted waters of our changing climate.

Read also:

Latest

Enhancing Low-Frequency Antenna Performance

Enhancing Low-Frequency Antenna Performance

The revival of interest in very low frequency (VLF) radio is due to the implementation of digital techniques. With the advent of software-defined radio, the requirement for large coils has been eliminated. Nevertheless, the need for certain components still persists.